The Comedy of Death

Game Rules

At a Glance…

Commedia dell’Arte, a form of popular theater that emerged in the 16th century and heralded the rise of the first troupes of masked Italian actors, inspired the first Killer Wink story: “The Comedy of Death.”

The game is easy to set up, easy to understand, and gets everyone involved right away.

I hope you enjoy some wonderful evenings of mystery and murder. And if you'd like to keep the fun going on other nights, there are three more games in the first season, offering progressively more challenging gameplay, more in-game events, and more strategies.

And now, let's get playing!

Take the time to read the rules below carefully. Explain them to your friends, use the example images to demonstrate how the game works, and don't leave anything out—every detail matters!

Will Kinker

Before You Begin

The host plays just like everyone else. There's no game master running the game without participating. The host is one of the players.

You can play with 6 to 18 players, but the experience is better with 8 to 10 players or more.

The game is recommended for ages 16 and up. However, younger players can also play, though they may find it harder to avoid rushing and stay discreet during the game.

Game length varies from 30 minutes to 2 hours when players are skillful and patient.

Set the Mood

If you'd like to give your party a theme, ask your friends to come dressed as Arlequin, Scapin, or Polichinelle, and recreate the atmosphere of a 17th-century Venetian salon. You're at Palazzo Aurelio. Set out small, ornate armchairs and a small round table. Hang large red and gold curtains. You can even put on a performance and speak to each other in grand, lyrical lines.

Game Setup

You'll form secret pairs. You'll know who your accomplice is, but you won't know who the other pairs are. Ideally, you'll have an even number of players, from 6 to 18. (If you're playing with an odd number, see “The King's Jester” under “Game Variants,” then continue with the rules below.)

To start, gather around a table to deal the cards. Once the pairs are formed, though, the game unfolds throughout your party—while enjoying pre-dinner drinks, out on the patio, in the kitchen, or over a meal. Killer Wink isn't played around a table; it unfolds in the background of your party.

Take one “Actor” card for each pair. Then take the “Accomplice” cards featuring the characters that match the “Actor” cards you selected. You should now have one card per player. (Important: if you have 6 players, you must create 4 pairs to allow for more player interaction. See “Shared Pairs” under “Game Variants,” then continue with the rules below.)

Players holding “Actor” cards won't know who their accomplice is at the start of the game. Players holding “Accomplice” cards will know the character of their Actor partner as soon as the cards are dealt, but they'll only discover which player has that character during the character introductions. During the game, they must let their Actor partner know they're on the same team. You can either shuffle all the selected cards together and deal them to the players, or shuffle the two groups of cards separately. In the second case, deal the “Accomplice” cards to players who want to know their partner's character from the beginning, and the “Actor” cards to everyone else.

You can also create mixed-gender pairs by dealing the “Actor” cards to women and the “Accomplice” cards to men, for example.

If you're playing with the “Shared Pairs” variant, deal the extra “Actor” cards after everyone has received one card. Give these extra cards only to players who are Actors.

Tell the Story of The Comedy of Death

“Venice, in the year 1610, is alive with laughter at the height of the Commedia dell’Arte's golden age. King Alphonse III, a discerning patron of the arts and a great lover of theater, is captivated by the troupe's exceptional performers and their dazzling show. To honor these masters of the stage, he invites them to his magnificent palace, Palazzo Aurelio.

To reward the performers' talent, he promises them a considerable sum of gold—a fortune that could change the life of every member of the troupe. Beneath the Venetian moonlight, Palazzo Aurelio welcomes an exquisite gathering of Commedia dell’Arte characters. Masks and costumes shimmer amid the splendor of the room reserved for the performers.

But among them, laughter fades and smiles conceal secret plots when the generous King Alphonse III unveils a chest of gold that shines as brightly as the stars above Venice. The lure of gold sparks secret alliances. The performers form pairs in the shadows, duos ready to share the riches—but also to betray one another to claim the entire treasure.

None of them knows that the other conspirators share the same goal, and Palazzo Aurelio becomes a stage for deadly intrigue. The dance begins. The pairs move gracefully through the palace, concealed among the shadows. A sinister ritual of death unfolds in its silent hallways, each murder cloaked in the elegance and refinement of the Commedia dell’Arte.

As alliances crumble and betrayals come to light, the golden comedy reaches its climax. Masks fall, and laughter gives way to silence. The last surviving performers face each other in a final duel, intoxicated by the lure of gold.”

Let the Mystery Begin

You've just dealt the “Accomplice” and “Actor” cards. Each player looks at their card without showing it to anyone else, then places it back on the table.

The Actors now reveal their cards so the Accomplices can identify their partners. One at a time, the Actors turn their cards face up in front of them and announce their character: “I am…”

Each Accomplice can then identify their Actor partner by checking the character on the “Accomplice” card they keep secret.

At the end of this round, each Accomplice may keep their secret card with them to prove their identity to their partner. The “Actor” cards may remain on the table.

To make the game easier, you may decide that players are not allowed to lie when telling their partners they are on the same team (see “Secret Partnership”). If you choose this rule, there's no need to keep your “Accomplice” cards with you as proof. You can return them to the deck.

Objective

Each secret pair must eliminate all the other players and, in the end, eliminate their own accomplice to become the sole survivor and keep King Alphonse III's treasure.

Secret Partnership

First, each Accomplice must tell their secret Actor partner that the two of them are working together against everyone else. They must do so discreetly during the party. If you decided to keep the “Accomplice” cards, they can show their card to prove who they are. They can also simply say it, wink, or give a knowing look—but both players must clearly understand that they're partners.

Elimination

At Palazzo Aurelio, a kill takes two players. To eliminate someone, one member of a pair must stand behind the target while the other stands in front. The player behind places a hand on the target's shoulder, while the player in front winks at the target and says, “The Treasure Is Ours.”

The player in the middle now knows they've been killed. They are no longer allowed to talk about the game. For the rest of the game, they must not reveal anything they know.

The eliminated player can no longer eliminate anyone else, and neither can their accomplice. To let everyone know they've been eliminated, the player must loudly announce “Elimination!” at the game table to gather everyone around. They then state that they've been eliminated and name their accomplice, who is eliminated as well.

Important: when someone places a hand on your shoulder, you are not allowed to close your eyes or avoid looking at the player facing you. Be a good sport and accept being eliminated when it happens. If you're eliminated, wait at least 5 to 10 minutes before telling the other players. Don't reveal your elimination to everyone too quickly.

Judgment

If a player has figured out or witnessed who is paired together, they may return to the game table and call out “Judgment!” so everyone can hear. All players must then gather around the table. The player who called for Judgment announces: “I accuse … and … of conspiring to murder us all.”

If the two accused players really are partners, they must admit it and are eliminated. If they aren't partners, the accuser and their accomplice are eliminated instead. As with other eliminations, eliminated players must not discuss the plot with the remaining players.

So be careful not to be seen when eliminating someone with a touch and a wink! If another player sees you, they can expose you to everyone and eliminate both you and your accomplice.

End of the Game

When only two pairs remain, whichever pair calls for Judgment first can use deduction to eliminate the other pair.

Only the final pair remains. The last two surviving Actors must then face each other in one final duel.

Final Duel

The final pair splits into two independent players. Each of them chooses a “Ghost” from among the eliminated players to become their new accomplice. During the rest of the party, they must discreetly let that player know, either by telling them or with a wink.

The game continues with these two new pairs and the same elimination rules, using a wink or Judgment. Once one of the new pairs is eliminated, the Actor on the surviving pair—not the Ghost—wins. They take King Alphonse III's treasure, leaving the fallen performers of The Comedy of Death behind…

Start Playing!

Everything's ready. Remember who you are and what you need to do. Play throughout the party while doing other things: having a drink around a table, chatting, cooking, setting the table, stepping onto the patio, eating, dancing, heading outside, or even playing other games. Killer Wink isn't played around a table; it unfolds in the background of your party.

Feel free to start another game if the first one ends too quickly. Players are sometimes too eager and not discreet enough during their first game.

Tips

Be discreet with your partner. Exchange glances, but don't spend too much time visibly together. Lure other players into separate rooms where you're alone with your targets. Watch the other players and where they go. Observe eliminations and work out who was with an eliminated player shortly beforehand. Regularly count how many players are still in the game so you're not caught off guard when only two pairs remain. If you play well, you'll have a chance to kill everyone—even your own accomplice—and leave alone with King Alphonse III's treasure…

Game Variants

The King's Jester

If you have an odd number of players, you may add an “Accomplice” card while dealing. Show its character to everyone before adding it to the cards to be shuffled and dealt. Whoever receives that card becomes “King Alphonse III's Jester.” This player disrupts the game. They play alone, because no “Actor” card matches their character. They can eliminate players through Judgment when they figure out a pair. They cannot kill anyone because they have no partner, but they are hard to identify. Other players can kill the Jester with a touch and a wink, or eliminate them through Judgment by accusing them of being “the King's Jester, hiding behind a mask to watch us all.” Beware of the King's Jester, who often ends up recovering the treasure for his good King Alphonse III, leaving all the dead Actors behind…

Shared Pairs

If you have too few players (6), an odd number of players, or simply want more interaction and more pairs, you can deal two “Actor” cards to each player who is an Actor, while still dealing only one “Accomplice” card to each Accomplice. With 6 players, for example, 2 players each receive 2 “Actor” cards, and 4 players each receive 1 “Accomplice” card. This creates 4 pairs: each Actor belongs to 2 pairs, while each Accomplice belongs to only 1. The rules remain the same, but an Actor cannot call for Judgment against either of their own pairs. When one of their pairs is eliminated, that Actor can continue playing with their second pair. Actors must be especially careful to manage both pairs and work with each partner to eliminate the others.

One Against All

An eliminated player's accomplice may continue playing. They cannot eliminate other players, but they can expose any pairs they discover in an attempt to be the sole survivor at the end of the game.

The Killer Wink

If some players aren't comfortable with a hand on their shoulder, you can play without physical contact. In that case, the player standing in front of the target winks at them. The target must then turn around. The player behind the target also winks to confirm the elimination. The player in the middle now knows they've been eliminated. However, the original shoulder-touch version is more direct and improves the game.

Large Groups

For company events, or simply when you're playing with a crowd, you can accommodate a large number of players: 36, 54, 72, or even more.

You'll need as many copies of the game as your group requires, with one card per person. Using a black marker, draw a thick line across the character side of every card in the second set. Use a red marker for a third set, and so on.

Cards showing the same character can then be distinguished. If your partner's character has a black line through it, you'll know you're paired with the player holding the matching black-marked character—not the one marked in red or left unmarked.

Your Feedback Matters

If you enjoyed the game or have suggestions for improvement, please share your experience on Amazon. It makes a huge difference to independent creators.

Killer Wink is also on Instagram. Follow us to discover what's new.

@killerwinkofficial

Questions?

Send me your questions through the contact form in the site's menu. I'll reply as soon as I can. You're also welcome to share your comments or suggestions for improving the game using that form. Thank you.

Buy the Game on Amazon

The pocket version of the game is available in English on Amazon.